The Push for a Vaping Crackdown
The Australian Medical Association was in Canberra on Friday advocating for the passage of new laws to crack down on vaping, expected to be voted on in June. However, Labor’s proposed ban on the importation and penalties for commercial possession of vapes hasn’t been smooth sailing.
Political Parties’ Standpoints
The Nationals propose that vapes be regulated like cigarettes, requiring no prescription and subject to the same rules on plain packaging and excise taxes. Meanwhile, the Liberals, influenced by their junior Coalition partner, and their shadow education minister, Sarah Henderson, who describes vapes as a “scourge” in schools, show mixed responses to the prohibition.
The Greens’ Perspective
The crossbench and Greens, who usually offer a safer passage through the Senate, also have their reservations. Jordon Steele-John, the Greens’ health spokesperson, supports the bill in principle but insists on amendments to prevent criminalising adults using vapes. The Greens aim to establish a “carefully regulated scheme that focuses on public health outcomes, reducing harm and minimising the use of vaping products.”
Challenges and Amendments
The Greens are concerned about potentially criminalising users of illegally obtained vapes despite a personal use exemption. They suggest that the definition of a “commercial quantity” of vapes, which could lead to criminal charges, be clearly defined in the legislation rather than left to regulations.
AMA’s Appeal
The AMA president, Steve Robson, expressed disappointment that some parliamentarians seem more influenced by tobacco-based lobby groups than by public health considerations. He urged all parties to prioritize the protection of Australian children from vaping.
The Legislative Debate
The bill presents a harsher regulatory regime for vapes than for cigarettes, despite cigarettes being more harmful, raising questions about the fairness and effectiveness of such a policy. Health Minister Mark Butler highlighted the opportunity to act decisively on vapes before they become as entrenched as cigarettes have historically been.
Moving Forward
With the bill set for a vote in June, the Australian government faces the challenge of balancing strict regulation to protect youth, while ensuring that adults who use vapes as a cessation tool are not unduly penalized.
